This post covers: why shopify checkouts lose revenue, simplify the checkout form, add trust badges at the right moment, offer multiple payment methods, fix shipping cost surprises, cart recovery email sequences.
1. Why Shopify Checkouts Lose Revenue
Cart abandonment on Shopify averages around 70%. That means for every 10 people who add something to their cart, only 3 actually complete the purchase. And the reasons are rarely about the product itself.
The top reasons people abandon Shopify checkouts (based on Baymard Institute data and our own client accounts): unexpected shipping costs (48%), being forced to create an account (24%), a checkout process that felt too long (17%), and not trusting the site with payment info (18%). Notice something? Almost all of these are fixable.
The changes below are ordered by impact. Start with the first few and work your way down. Each one targets a specific friction point that we've seen consistently reduce abandonment across dozens of Shopify stores.
2. Simplify the Checkout Form
Shopify's default checkout is already simpler than most platforms, which is one of its advantages. But there are still improvements you can make, especially if you've added custom fields or extra steps.
First, enable Shop Pay. Shopify's own data shows that Shop Pay checkouts convert 1.72x higher than regular checkouts because returning shoppers can auto-fill everything in one tap. If you don't have it enabled, do that before anything else. It's free and takes 5 minutes.
Second, enable guest checkout. Requiring account creation before purchase is one of the fastest ways to kill conversions. Let people buy first, then offer account creation on the thank-you page. They've already committed at that point.
Third, remove any optional form fields you don't actually need. Company name? Phone number? "How did you hear about us?" Each extra field adds friction. Ask yourself: do we use this data? If the answer is no, remove the field.
3. Add Trust Badges at the Right Moment
Trust badges work, but placement matters more than the badges themselves. The moment a visitor is about to enter their credit card number is the moment they're most anxious about security. That's where trust signals belong.
Place trust badges directly below or beside the payment form. A small "SSL Secured" icon, a "30-Day Money Back Guarantee" badge, and recognized payment logos (Visa, Mastercard, PayPal) can reduce checkout abandonment by 5-15%. These aren't massive numbers individually, but they compound with other fixes.
Don't overdo it though. A wall of 15 trust badges looks desperate, not trustworthy. Pick 3-4 that are relevant to your audience's concerns. If your customers ask about returns a lot, emphasize your guarantee. If they ask about shipping, highlight your shipping policy.
4. Offer Multiple Payment Methods
Not everyone wants to type in a credit card number on their phone. In 2026, buyers expect options. And the stores that give them options close more sales.
At minimum, Shopify stores should offer: credit/debit cards, Shop Pay, Apple Pay, Google Pay, and PayPal. If you sell higher-ticket items ($100+), add a buy-now-pay-later option like Klarna or Afterpay. BNPL options can increase average order value by 20-30% on products in the $100-$500 range.
Enabling these is mostly a settings change in Shopify Payments. Apple Pay and Google Pay are automatically available when you use Shopify Payments. PayPal requires connecting your PayPal business account. BNPL providers have their own Shopify apps.
5. Fix Shipping Cost Surprises
Unexpected shipping costs are the number one reason for cart abandonment. Not "one of the top reasons." The number one reason. Almost half of all abandoned carts happen because the shopper saw the shipping price and decided it wasn't worth it.
There are a few ways to handle this:
- Free shipping threshold: "Free shipping on orders over $50." This works for most stores and can increase AOV because shoppers add items to hit the threshold.
- Build shipping into product prices: Raise prices slightly and offer "free shipping on everything." The perceived value is higher even when the total cost is the same.
- Show shipping estimates early: Display estimated shipping cost on the product page or in the cart, before checkout. No surprises at the payment step.
The worst option is showing "$0.00 shipping" until the checkout page, then revealing a $12.99 shipping charge. That feels like a bait-and-switch, and visitors react accordingly.
6. Cart Recovery Email Sequences
Not everyone who abandons checkout is lost. About 10-15% of abandoned carts can be recovered through email sequences. That's revenue you already earned the click for and paid for with ad spend.
A basic abandoned cart email sequence for Shopify:
- Email 1 (1 hour after abandonment): Simple reminder. "You left something in your cart." Include a photo of the product and a direct link back to checkout. No discount yet.
- Email 2 (24 hours): Address the likely objection. Free shipping reminder, return policy, review highlights. Still no discount.
- Email 3 (48-72 hours): Offer a small incentive if needed. 10% off or free shipping. This is your last push.
Shopify has built-in abandoned checkout emails, but they're basic. Klaviyo or Omnisend give you more control over timing, content, and segmentation. The ROI on setting this up is usually very high because you're recovering sales from people who already showed purchase intent.
7. One-Page vs Multi-Step Checkout
Shopify rolled out one-page checkout in 2023, and the data since then has been interesting. For most stores, one-page checkout converts slightly better than multi-step (about 5-8% improvement). The reason is simple: fewer clicks, fewer chances to leave.
But one-page checkout isn't always better. Stores with complex products that require customization (engraving, personalization, bundle selection) sometimes perform better with a guided multi-step flow because it reduces cognitive load.
If you're on Shopify Plus, you can customize and test both. If you're on a standard plan, Shopify's default one-page checkout is probably your best option, and it's already enabled for new stores.
8. Post-Purchase Upsells
The moment after someone completes a purchase is the highest-trust moment in the entire customer relationship. They just gave you their money. They're feeling good about their decision. This is when post-purchase upsells convert at 10-15%, compared to 1-3% for pre-purchase upsells.
Post-purchase upsell apps for Shopify (like ReConvert or AfterSell) show an offer on the order confirmation page. The buyer can add the upsell item with one click, no need to re-enter payment information. Common offers include complementary products, product bundles, or subscription upgrades.
The key is relevance. If someone bought a coffee maker, offer filters or a grinder. If someone bought running shoes, offer socks. Don't show random products from your catalog. The more relevant the upsell, the higher the take rate and the lower the return rate.
For more on driving revenue from your existing traffic, check our CRO services page.
Frequently Asked Questions
A healthy checkout conversion rate (percentage of carts that complete purchase) is 30-40% for most Shopify stores. Top performers hit 45-55%. If your checkout rate is below 25%, there are likely fixable friction points in your checkout flow.
Yes. Shopify reports that Shop Pay checkouts convert 1.72x higher than regular guest checkouts. The main reason is auto-fill: returning Shop Pay users can complete checkout in one or two taps instead of typing all their information.
In most cases, yes. Unexpected shipping costs are the top reason for cart abandonment. If you can not absorb shipping costs entirely, set a free shipping threshold above your average order value to increase AOV while reducing abandonment.
Post-purchase upsells typically add 5-15% to total revenue for Shopify stores. The conversion rate on post-purchase offers is much higher than pre-purchase because the buyer has already committed and does not need to re-enter payment details.
Find Out What's Costing You
COREPPC's free audit checks your Google Ads and Meta accounts in 60 seconds. Get your performance score, spot wasted spend, and see exactly where to improve.
Start Free Audit
